What you already have
Microsoft Defender Antivirus is built into Windows and is a competent baseline. Defender for Business is the SME edition of Microsoft's EDR, included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and sold standalone per user. It adds attack-surface reduction, automated investigation and remediation, a vulnerability view and a security portal. If you have Business Premium, you are paying for it whether you use it or not.
What Sophos does that Defender for Business does not
- CryptoGuard rollback: file-level ransomware rollback without relying on shadow copies or OneDrive versioning.
- Synchronized Security: a Sophos Firewall isolates a compromised device automatically via the Security Heartbeat.
- Mac and Linux parity in the same console with the same policies.
- MDR as an upgrade path: the same agent goes from Advanced to XDR to a 24/7 human service by changing the licence; Microsoft's equivalent (Defender Experts) is an enterprise-tier product.
- Independence from your identity platform: protection does not depend on Entra ID licensing tiers or Intune enrolment to work fully.
What Defender does better
- It is already paid for in Business Premium.
- Tight integration with Intune, Entra ID conditional access and Microsoft 365 email security.
- One vendor, one bill, one portal if you are all-in on Microsoft.
The real cost of switching
Switching is a project: uninstall Sophos cleanly, enrol devices in Intune (Defender for Business onboarding is painful without it), rebuild policies, retrain whoever watches alerts, and run both for a period. For a 30-user business that is typically more than a year of Sophos renewal in labour. The sensible decision rule: if Sophos is working and you have no analyst, renew Intercept X Advanced; if you are already managing devices in Intune and have Business Premium everywhere, Defender for Business is a credible alternative at the next renewal; if you want 24/7 humans, Sophos MDR is the easier route for an SME.
Questions people ask
Can I run Defender and Sophos together?
Sophos Intercept X runs alongside Defender Antivirus in passive mode on Windows; Sophos manages that automatically. Running two full EDR products is not recommended.
Does Sophos protect Microsoft 365 email?
Sophos Email is a separate product; Defender for Office 365 covers mail in a Microsoft shop. Many Sophos customers keep Microsoft's email protection and use Sophos for endpoints, servers and the firewall.